OUGD503: Final Crit Workshop

by Roxxie Blackham on Thursday, 20 March 2014

Collaborative Feedback:















What are we looking for in terms of feedback for design boards:
- Effective layout of presentation - boards, consistency, project report, blog
- Project management:
   - how do you evidence it?
   - have you evidenced it?
   - is there enough evidence for the time available?
- Have you answered the brief(s)? If not, why not?
- Visual quality and technical ability
- Suggestions for improvement
- Evaluation
- What works? What doesn't? And why?

In our collaborative pairs, we were asked to give feedback to two other people around the table.

My feedback was as follows:

Effective Layout of presentations
Strengths
Clear and consistent

Suggestions
Even spacing between images on Secret 7" board (vertical gutter)
- Even spacing on Type Triathlon
- 1st person is not allowed - 3rd person only

Project Management
Strengths
- Time has been well managed
- Could show more evidence of development

Have you answered the brief(s)?
Strengths
- All briefs clearly present solutions to the problems provided
- Body Shop goes further than answering as it proposes apps etc

Suggestions
- Photograph in Type Triathlon - what is the relevance?

Visual Quality
Strengths
- Colour schemes wok well

Suggestions
- Hightone Book type could be smoother. The background of high tone work could be less intrusive

Leave your comment